Tidepool Learning IESLA2026-05-18T16:53:00-07:00 Advanced This field is hidden when viewing the formAdvanced or Conceptual - HiddenAdvancedConceptualThis field is hidden when viewing the formProject Name Design Narrative Max. Value 20 PointsDesign Narrative Max. Value 15 PointsHow well does the student describe their design? Does the narrative address: The designer’s creative vision, plan for execution, luminaire selection, lighting techniques, and use of controls?*Please enter a number from 1 to 20.1-4 – Poor 5-8 – Below Standard 9-12 – Meets Expectations 13-16 – Exceeds Expectations 17-20 – Distinctive/ExcellentHow well does the student describe their design? Does the narrative address: The designer’s creative vision, plan for execution, luminaire selection, lighting techniques, and use of controls?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentDesign Narrative CommentsNot required. Imagery / Drawing Clarity Max. Value 15 PointsDo the drawings and visual imagery clearly illustrate the locations and intention for each light? Is there imagery for each light type? Does the imagery support the design intent?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentImagery / Drawing Clarity CommentsNot required. Drawings / Renderings Max. Value 15 PointsDo the drawings clearly illustrate the locations and installation intent for each light? Are the symbol key and light types shown? Do the renderings clearly depict the lighting effects and accurately represent the lighting of the selected fixtures?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentDrawing / Renderings CommentsNot required. Schedules / Title 24 / Photometrics Max. Value 15 PointsDo the schedules include fixture type, image, description, manufacturer & catalog number, lamp/source information, and relevant notes? Does the presentation include Title 24 observations including: the codes estimated allowed wattage, project watts per foot, and how they met their energy allowance?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentSchedules / Title 24 / Photometrics CommentsNot required. Control Intent Max. Value 10 PointsDoes the imagery and narrative clearly present a dimming/control scheme?*Please enter a number from 1 to 10.1-2 – Poor 3-4 – Below Standard 5-6 – Meets Expectations 7-8 – Exceeds Expectations 9-10 – Distinctive/ExcellentDo the drawings clearly present control zones and how they will be used? Is there a dimming/control scheme? Were there descriptions of the lighting presets for each of the venue's purposes?*Please enter a number from 1 to 10.1-2 – Poor 3-4 – Below Standard 5-6 – Meets Expectations 7-8 – Exceeds Expectations, 9-10 – Distinctive/ExcellentControl Intent CommentsNot required. Design Intent & Creativity Max. Value 20 Points Design Intent & Creativity Max. Value 15 PointsIs the design intent clear and creative? Does the designer have a clear and distinctive point of view in their design? Does the design demonstrate creativity or innovation?*Please enter a number from 1 to 20.1-4 – Poor 5-8 – Below Standard 9-12 – Meets Expectations 13-16 – Exceeds Expectations 17-20 – Distinctive/ExcellentIs the design intent clear and creative? Does the designer have a clear and distinctive point of view in their design? Does the design demonstrate creativity or innovation?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentDesign Intent CommentsNot required. Meeting the Challenge Max. Value 15 PointsIs the design intent appropriate the challenge outlined in the brief? Do the fixture selections work with the architectural conditions?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentMeeting the Challenge CommentsNot required. Execution Max. Value 15 Points Execution Max. Value 10 PointsDo the drawings and plans achieve the design intent outlined the visuals and narrative? Will the fixture selections achieve the desired effect?*Please enter a number from 1 to 15.1-3 – Poor 4-6 – Below Standard 7-9 – Meets Expectations 10-12 – Exceeds Expectations 13-15 – Distinctive/ExcellentDo the drawings and plans achieve the design intent outlined the visuals and narrative? Will the fixture selections achieve the desired effect?*Please enter a number from 1 to 10.1-2 – Poor 3-4 – Below Standard 5-6 – Meets Expectations 7-8 – Exceeds Expectations 9-10 – Distinctive/ExcellentExecution CommentsNot required. Discretionary Points Max. Value 5 PointsPoints for creativity and exemplary design development.*Please enter a number from 1 to 5.1-5 – Distinctive/ExcellentDiscretionary CommentsNot required. TOTAL POINTS POSSIBLE: 100 TOTAL POINTSPlease leave this field blank. The form will tally the total automatically.Do you have any overall feedback you would like to pass on to the student to help them in future lighting projects? These comments may be passed on to the students or instructors so please keep the comments constructive!
